Promoted by loans.com.au
Adding value to an investment property is a powerful way to boost returns. Enhancements could translate to higher rental income, increased resale value, or long-term capital growth.
But as construction costs surge and planning regulations evolve, investors must carefully consider whether renovating or knocking it down altogether is the right decision.
Renovating vs Redeveloping: What's the Difference?
At its simplest, renovating refers to improving an existing structure. This typically involves cosmetic updates like a fresh coat of paint and new fittings, substantial upgrades such as kitchen or bathroom overhauls, or extensions to increase space.
Redeveloping, on the other hand, often entails knocking down the existing dwelling to rebuild, subdividing the land, or constructing multiple dwellings like duplexes. These strategies come with higher capital outlays as the job tends to be more extensive than a renovation, and often means starting from scratch.
When Renovating Makes More Sense
Renovating is typically more cost-effective when the property is structurally sound, the layout is functional, and the area doesn't support major redevelopment (due to zoning or buyer demand). It's also quicker, less disruptive to tenants, and often easier to finance.
Some of the highest-yielding renovations in 2025 include:
- Kitchen upgrades - Modernising benchtops, cabinetry and appliances can drastically lift value.
- Bathroom refreshes - Replacing outdated tiles and fittings is a strong drawcard for tenants and buyers.
- Cosmetic facelifts - Paint, new flooring, lighting and kerb appeal can boost rental return with minimal investment.
- Outdoor improvements - Adding decks or enhancing outdoor living spaces increases both desirability and perceived value.
When Rebuilding Pays Off
Alternatively, there are times when the existing property is holding the land back. Perhaps the structure is severely outdated, riddled with issues, or simply not suited to modern demand.
If land value exceeds the value of the house, it might make more sense to demolish and rebuild, or subdivide.
This is especially true in areas undergoing urban renewal or medium-density rezoning, locations with large blocks ideal for dual occupancy or townhouses, and sites near infrastructure or public transport where infill development is encouraged
While the upfront costs are higher compared to renovating, these rebuilding strategies can potentially deliver 15-25% returns, particularly if the end product meets market demand.
Risks to Watch Out For When Employing Value-Adding Strategies
While improvements and overhauls may boost returns, they come with risks that can erode profits if not properly assessed and managed.
Overcapitalisation
Spending more on upgrades than the market will return is one of the most common traps for investors. Pouring $150,000 into custom fixtures and high-end finishes in a suburb where buyers are only willing to pay an extra $80,000 for such features is a recipe for negative equity.
This risk is heightened in areas with slower growth or limited buyer demand, where flashy improvements might not translate into higher valuations or rental returns.
Build Cost Blowouts
With material prices still elevated and skilled labour in short supply across many regions, what starts as a $50,000 renovation can quickly balloon to $70,000 or more. Be mindful of supply chain delays, mid-project changes, and unforeseen structural issues when planning a renovation or redevelopment.
For rebuilds or large-scale developments, cost overruns can stretch into a couple of thousand dollars, impacting not just the project budget but also your cash flow and borrowing capacity.
Extended Vacancy Periods
Renovations and redevelopments often require properties to be vacant for weeks or even months. If you rely on rental income to service loans, these vacancy periods can put significant pressure on finances, especially if timelines blow out unexpectedly.
Properties in tight rental markets might be easier to re-let post-upgrade, but extended downtimes can still dent annual yields and stretch repayment buffers.
Approval Delays and Regulatory Roadblocks
Planning approvals, building permits, and local council processes can be notoriously slow and complex. Changes in zoning laws, increased compliance checks, or backlogs in council assessments can delay your project by weeks or even months, increasing holding costs like mortgage repayments, council rates, and insurance.
If your project requires development approval (DA), remember to budget for both the time and the cost of professional planning and compliance support to prevent approval delays, unexpected bills, or even DA rejection.
The statutory assessment period for most councils is 40-90 days, but this can extend significantly depending on the project's complexity and council workload.
Other Factors to Consider When Renovating or Rebuilding
Consider your investment goal. Are you chasing yield, capital growth, or resale profit? From there, decide whether a value-adding project would help you achieve it.
Another important piece of the puzzle is time and cash flow. Can you afford an extended vacancy period to make way for a complete rebuild? Do you have the capacity to service construction debt?
In some cases, a coat of paint and kitchen upgrade may deliver a faster, safer return than a full-scale redevelopment. In others, subdivision or rebuilds can unlock major equity gains. Carefully evaluate what your investment property truly needs.
Ultimately, the best strategy comes down to local market knowledge, risk appetite, and long-term planning. Don't just follow the renovation trend; crunch the numbers, speak to professionals, and make sure your value-adding plan is aligned with your investment goals.
At loans.com.au, we're here to help you get your finance sorted so you can rebuild your home or complete your renovations. The entire process, from application to settlement, can be completed online, over the phone, or via email.
Image by Blue Bird on Pexels
