CASE STUDY | $50,000+, a nice short term profit. This is why I said NO!

Everyone would say Yes to a potential $50,000 profit right?

Well maybe just about everyone but me!

Let me paint the picture:

On a recent post on Social Media someone was asking;

“Would you consider buying in a low socio-economic location if the numbers looked good?”

Not really enough information here, but I held firm and simply said No.

They went on to explain, even if I could buy it at a cheap price, give it a quick renovation increase the equity by more than $50,000 and it would rent out for a high yield.

While there were shouts of “Yes”…. “Go for it”…… “Absolutely”…. I held my ground and still said No!

I am quite certain everyone thought I was crazy, just as you may now.

My Logic

While there is still not enough information here to make an informed decision, I will generalise.

First of all, the best piece of advice I have been given while investing, goes something like this;

“Never make long term decisions, based on short term information”

You see everyone who said yes to this scenario, is focussed on the short term – the $50,000.

They also made another critical error in assuming that everything would go to plan and you would achieve the best case scenario;

· The purchase would go to plan at the right price

· There would be no significant issues or cost blow outs with the renovation

· It would be easy to find a tenant paying the desired rent (in a low socio economic environment)

· The valuation would stack up at the end valuation

In my, nearly two decades on property investing experience, it would not surprise me in the current environment if one of two of these (at least) did not go to plan.

This is the risk of the transaction alone, let alone the idea of holding on to the asset and renting it out for the medium to longer term.

That opens up an another entire conversation.

The Risk with Outer Suburbs

Over the medium to longer term there is greater risk in these low-socioeconomic, outer suburbs.

They are usually in areas that are a considerable distance from major employment hubs and hence have lower wages growth.

Wages only keep up with inflation at best and in many cases struggle to do that.

Unfortunately, this demographic are mostly living pay check to pay check.

I would suggest at some stage over the next decade we will see some sort of Economic or Financial crash and these areas will be hardest hit.

In the unlikely event we miss a crash, interest rates will eventually begin to rise at some stage in the future and again, lower income earners will feel the pressure.

These areas are also often touted as the next hotspot or have large amounts of land still to be developed and often attract the investor crowd.

Again, if events conspire to a downturn, Investors won’t hang around and will shift their capital quickly to get out, leading to a downward spiral for property prices.

Reduce the Risk

I would prefer to focus on the longer term and reduce risk.

Focus on areas with a High Owner Occupier percentage, where most of the demographic own the property or are paying off a mortgage.

Home owners are in it for the longer term and will not give up their homes so easily, this leads to less market volatility.

At Metropole, we are chasing a certain kind of Owner Occupier;

In our research at Metropole we look for suburbs where the locals have a high disposable incomes.

We look for locations where home owners have a higher weekly Income than average and locations where the wages growth is above the state average, because these are suburbs where the locals have a high disposable incomes.

We also look for locations close to major employment hubs where jobs are plentiful.


Brett Warren is a director of Metropole Properties in Brisbane and uses his 12 plus years property investment experience and economics education to advice clients how to build their portfolios.

He is a regular commentator for Michael Yardney's Property Update.

Disclaimer: while due care is taken, the viewpoints expressed by contributors do not necessarily reflect the opinions of Your Investment Property.