fork-in-the-road-han-chieh-lee-pexels.jpg

I've been investing in property for over 20 years, and one question I still get asked is whether investors should focus on capital growth or cash flow.

My answer has always been pretty simple. Why not both?

But looking at the Australian property market right now, I think investors need to pay more attention to what their properties are actually bringing in.

See also:

With higher interest rates, softer prices in some markets and mortgage repayments putting pressure on household budgets, it's a different environment from the one many investors became comfortable with.

And I think it's exposing a mistake that's been made for years.

Capital growth is great, but it doesn't pay the mortgage

Don't get me wrong. I'm a big believer in capital growth. It's how many Australians have built substantial wealth through property.

But there's something I regularly remind investors:

You can't use capital growth to pay your mortgage each month unless you sell, refinance or access equity.

Some investors buy a property expecting it to increase in value, accept a low rental return and assume everything will work itself out.

That can be easier when rates are low and prices are climbing. But what happens when growth slows and repayments keep going up?

You still need to find that money somewhere.

Recent market figures have shown gross rental yields improving in some markets as property values softened. 

But there's an important distinction: a yield can rise because a property's value has dropped, not because the owner is collecting more rent.

See also: Rental yields hit 11-year high as home prices fall

For me, that's another reason to focus on the actual dollars coming in.

Here's an example I often discuss with investors

co-living-artbovich-pexels.jpg

A property suitable for co-living could potentially generate higher rental income than a standard rental.

Let's say you're looking at two properties, both priced at $800,000.

The first is a standard four-bedroom house renting for $650 a week. That's $33,800 annually, or around 4.2% gross yield.

The second is suitable for co-living and could potentially generate $1,100 a week across multiple rooms. That's $57,200 a year, or around 7.2% gross yield.

Same purchase price, but a difference of $23,400 in annual rental income.

Now assume you've borrowed 80% at 6.5% interest. On an interest-only basis, that's approximately $41,600 a year in interest.

The first property's rent doesn't cover the interest, even before rates, insurance and maintenance.

The second gives you considerably more breathing room, although it still won’t necessarily be cash-flow positive.

Co-living can involve higher management costs, furnishing, maintenance, vacancies and compliance requirements. It's not suitable for every property or investor.

See also: When does co-living become a rooming house? A guide for investors

Still, it shows what a difference the right rental strategy can make.

I don't believe in chasing yield alone

Here's where I think some people misunderstand cash flow investing.

Just because a property offers an 8% or 9% gross rental yield doesn't automatically make it a good investment.

I've looked at properties with attractive rental returns in locations where I wouldn't personally want to invest. You still need to consider local jobs, population growth, infrastructure, tenant demand and the property's long-term appeal.

What's the point of a high advertised yield if you struggle to find tenants or the property’s value declines over time?

For me, the ideal investment is an established property in a location with solid growth fundamentals, and where there's also an opportunity to improve the income.

That might involve a granny flat, dual occupancy or co-living, provided the numbers stack up and the required approvals are in place.

Sometimes it's simply about negotiating a better purchase price.

The biggest mistake is buying something you can't afford to hold

One thing I've learnt over the years is that investing isn't just about how much wealth you might create. It's also about whether you can afford to stay in the market.

Imagine owning three properties, each costing you $400 a week out of pocket.

That's $1,200 a week, or $62,400 a year.

That's a lot of money to keep finding, especially when you have a family and other financial commitments.

And if your circumstances change, you might end up selling at exactly the wrong time.

Cash flow matters even more as a portfolio grows. It gives you options and helps you ride out the tougher periods.

What would I do in today's market?

If I were buying another investment property today, I wouldn't rush in just because prices have fallen.

I'd check the real rental demand, calculate the holding costs and allow for vacancies, repairs and unexpected expenses.

I'd also test whether I could still afford the property if interest rates rose another 1%.

Then I'd look at the growth potential and whether I could improve the property's income without taking on unnecessary risk.

Most importantly, I'd ask myself one question: Will this purchase put me in a stronger financial position five or 10 years from now?

See also: When property market is falling, smart investors start looking

Buying one investment property is relatively easy. Building a portfolio you can comfortably hold through different market cycles is the real challenge.

Capital growth is what builds your wealth. Cash flow is what helps you keep it.

And when you can find both in the same property, that’s where the real opportunity lies.

Images from Pexels

See more YIP in Google
See more Your Investment Property in Google

Do you like & trust our expert, human-written content?

Simply click this button to tell Google you want to see more of us in your Google Search Results, AI Overviews and AI Mode answers.