Promoted by loans.com.au
Each path has pros, cons, and compliance implications. Understanding the difference between an SMSF commercial loan and a traditional home loan for commercial properties can help you understand which one suits your situation and strategy.
What is an SMSF Commercial Loan?
An SMSF commercial loan is a loan taken out by a self-managed super fund to acquire a commercial property, structured under a limited recourse borrowing arrangement (LRBA). Under LRBA rules, the lender's recourse is limited to the property used as security - other assets of the SMSF are protected in case of default.
Because of this constrained structure, SMSF commercial loans must satisfy strict superannuation law requirements (e.g. sole purpose test, investment strategy) and cannot be used for improvements or development financed by borrowed funds.
Eligibility requirements for SMSF commercial loans
Your SMSF must demonstrate compliance with superannuation law before a lender will even consider approving finance. Being fully compliant with ATO rules means you have lodged returns on time and are not under any regulatory sanctions. Lenders typically want evidence of a clean compliance history.
Trustees must provide a documented investment strategy that specifically allows for property investment. Documentation required may include the following:
- SMSF trust deed and custodian (bare trust) deed
- SMSF financial statements and tax returns (typically two years)
- Member contribution history
- Independent property valuation
- Evidence of sufficient cash reserves in the fund to cover costs such as stamp duty, legal fees, and liquidity buffers
What is a Traditional Commercial Loan?
A traditional commercial loan is a loan provided to an individual, company, trust, or business for acquisition, development, or investment in commercial property. The borrower's broader balance sheet and business cash flow typically underpin the loan, not just the property itself.
Traditional commercial loans offer more flexibility in purpose (e.g. refinancing, development, expansions), subject to lender policies and risk assessments. And unlike SMSF loans, traditional commercial lending is not constrained by superannuation laws; the lender can have recourse to the borrower's other assets on default.
Eligibility requirements for traditional commercial loans
By contrast, traditional commercial loans are assessed on more familiar banking criteria, with a focus on the borrower's creditworthiness and the property's cash flow profile. They are not bound by superannuation law, giving lenders and borrowers more flexibility.
Key requirements include:
- Borrower's profile - Applicants may be individuals, companies, partnerships, or trusts. Lenders will review personal and/or business credit history, existing debt, and financial stability.
- Business and income - Banks place strong weight on business revenues, operating history, and debt servicing capacity. Evidence may include profit and loss statements, tax returns, and bank statements
- Property information - Lenders typically look at location, lease terms, tenant quality, vacancy history, and long-term demand for that type of property.
- Security position - LVRs can be higher than with SMSF loans, often up to 70-80%, which reduces the upfront capital required. However, because these loans are usually full recourse, the lender may have claims against the borrower's other assets in the event of default.
- Track record - Lenders generally prefer borrowers with a history of managing commercial property or running a business successfully. Strong borrower experience can help secure better rates and terms.
Which one should you choose?
SMSF commercial loans and traditional commercial loans each cater to different investor profiles and strategic priorities.
SMSF commercial loans are compliance-heavy and less flexible, but they keep risk contained within the fund and may deliver long-term retirement benefits when structured correctly.
That said, an SMSF commercial loan may be ideal for investors whose strategy is long-term retirement income rather than speculative flips, as you can only use the funds to acquire the asset, not develop or upgrade it. It's also ideal where tax and super benefits (tax-efficient accumulation and pension phase benefits) are central to the strategy.
Traditional commercial loans, on the other hand, are more flexible and easier to manage. However, the trade-off for this relative ease and convenience is that they expose the borrower's personal or business assets to greater risk (in case they default).
The optimal path depends on your investment horizon, risk appetite, SMSF capacity, and financial structure. Always seek advice from SMSF specialists, accountants, and commercial finance brokers before proceeding.
If you have questions, you can book a free consultation with one of our SMSF lending experts through this link: https://www.loans.com.au/home-loans/smsf-commercial-loan/. We offer SMSF commercial loans with competitive fixed and variable rates and up to 80% LVR.
Image by Nastuh Abootalebi on Unsplash
